Guess Again Summary: A Gripping Psychological Thriller That Keeps You Guessing

Introduction: Why Guess Again is the Thriller You Can’t Miss

If you’re a fan of psychological thrillers that combine heart-pounding suspense with deep emotional complexity, Guess Again by Charlie Donlea is a must-read. This masterfully crafted novel plunges you into the eerie, small-town mystery of a teenage girl’s decade-old disappearance, weaving together past secrets, dangerous truths, and shocking twists.

In this Guess Again summary, we explore how Donlea creates a suspenseful atmosphere that will keep you hooked from page one until the jaw-dropping finale.

Set in a quiet Wisconsin town, Guess Again brings to life the chilling investigation of Callie Jones, a high school volleyball star who vanished without a trace ten years ago. As the anniversary of her disappearance approaches, the cold case is reignited under the scrutiny of Ethan Hall, a former detective turned ER doctor. But this is more than a straightforward mystery—the novel explores dark psychological games, haunted pasts, and the lengths people will go to protect deadly secrets.

Read on for an in-depth look at Guess Again and why it deserves a spot on your thriller reading list.

Who is Charlie Donlea? The Author Behind Guess Again

Charlie Donlea is a bestselling American author known for his gripping psychological thrillers and suspense novels. He gained significant recognition for his 2021 book Guess Again, a cleverly plotted mystery that keeps readers guessing until the very end.

About Charlie Donlea:

• Background: Before becoming a full-time writer, Donlea worked in the television industry, which may contribute to his sharp, cinematic storytelling style.

• Writing Style: His books often feature intricate twists, unreliable narrators, and fast-paced plots that appeal to fans of authors like Harlan Coben and Mary Kubica.

• Popular Works: Besides Guess Again, some of his well-known novels include:

  • The Girl Who Was Taken (2017)

  • Don’t Believe It (2018)

  • Some Choose Darkness (2019)

  • Twenty Years Later (2021)

Guess Again Summary: What Happens in Guess Again?

At the core of Guess Again is the haunting disappearance of Callie Jones, a 17-year-old volleyball star from Cherryview, Wisconsin. Her vanishing ten years earlier shocked the community and spawned a widely publicized search. Despite the extensive efforts, Callie was never found, and the case went cold—until now.

Ethan Hall, who once worked as a renegade detective in the kid crime division, left law enforcement to become an ER doctor, hoping to escape the horrors he witnessed. However, when his dying former partner, Pete Kramer, implores him to reopen Callie’s case, Ethan is pulled back into a world he tried to leave behind.

As Ethan delves deeper into the investigation during a sweltering heatwave, he quickly realizes that revisiting old evidence won’t be enough. Dangerous new secrets surface, revealing chilling connections to his own dark past. His probing draws him into a psychological battle with unexpected players—like Francis, an imprisoned serial killer who seems to hold secrets about Callie’s disappearance despite not being involved.

This investigation unravels a twisted web of deception, betrayal, and deadly secrets—forcing readers to constantly guess again who to trust and what the truth really is.

Key Characters: The People Behind the Mystery

• Ethan Hall: Former detective turned ER doctor; protagonist tasked with solving Callie’s cold case. His haunted past and unconventional investigative methods drive much of the narrative tension.

• Callie Jones: The teenage volleyball star whose disappearance ten years ago remains unsolved. Daughter of the governor, her case has political and emotional stakes.

• Pete Kramer: Ethan’s former partner, now dying, whose conscience pushes Ethan to seek justice.

• Francis: An imprisoned serial killer with surprising knowledge about the case, adding psychological depth and complexity to the mystery.

• The Town of Cherryview: Almost a character itself, the small Wisconsin town is filled with secrets and tensions, where everyone feels the weight of Callie’s disappearance.

What Makes Guess Again Stand Out? (5 Reasons)

1. Intricate Plot With Unpredictable Twists

Donlea expertly crafts a narrative full of surprising turns that challenge readers’ assumptions. Just when you think you’ve figured it out, the story forces you to guess again.

2. Rich Psychological Suspense

The novel explores the mental and emotional struggles of its characters, especially Ethan’s inner conflicts and the psychological games he faces during the investigation.

3. Strong Sense of Place and Atmosphere

The quiet, lake-side town of Cherryview provides an atmospheric backdrop that intensifies the novel’s tension, especially under the heatwave that mirrors the rising stakes.

4. Multi-layered Characters

Every character feels complex and real, each with their own secrets and motivations, which adds depth and realism to the story.

5. Emotional Stakes and Social Commentary

The book touches on themes like grief, justice, and the impact of unresolved trauma on individuals and communities.

Themes Explored in Guess Again

• Justice and Closure: The pursuit of truth to bring peace to families and communities.

• Memory and Trauma: How past events shape present actions and perceptions.

• Trust and Deception: Who can be believed when everyone has secrets?

• Psychological Complexity: The mental toll of crime and investigation on those involved.

• Community Impact: How a small town wrestles with collective trauma.

Reader Experience: Why You’ll Love This Book

Readers have praised Guess Again for its:

• Relentless suspense that keeps pages turning

• Well-developed characters that resonate emotionally

• Thought-provoking mystery that challenges your detective skills

• Shockingly satisfying ending that stays with you long after finishing

Fans of Riley Sager, Karin Slaughter, and Ashley Flowers will find Donlea’s style equally gripping.

Final Thoughts: Should You Read Guess Again?

Guess Again by Charlie Donlea is a tightly woven psychological thriller that expertly balances suspense, character depth, and emotional complexity. Its twisty narrative and layered storytelling make it a rewarding read for thriller lovers who enjoy puzzles and dark secrets. If you appreciate a novel that keeps you guessing until the last page, this book is a perfect fit.

Don’t miss out on this captivating story—read Guess Again and discover why Charlie Donlea is quickly becoming a major figure in suspense fiction.

Ready to dive in? Get your copy today and experience the thrill of guessing again!

Explore More Like This

Check out our summaries of:

•  The Tenant Book Summary: A Gripping and Disturbing Psychological Thriller You Must Read
• Julie Chan Is Dead Summary: A Twisted Dive into Influencer Culture

Get Your Copy

• Guess Again by Charlie Donlea
• Explore Similar Books

Attachments & References

• Amazon’s book page
• Goodreaders’s book page
• Author’s image source: x.com
• Book Cover: Amazon.com
• Quote sources: Goodreads