First-Time Caller Summary – A Heartfelt Radio Romance That Heals the Soul

In First-Time Caller, B.K. Borison delivers a beautifully calibrated romance that resonates far beyond the boundaries of a standard love story. With the familiar charm of small-town connection and the fresh novelty of a late-night radio show as its central narrative device, Borison skillfully melds vulnerability, wit, and emotional realism. The novel takes readers on an affecting journey of self-discovery, second chances, and the tender, often awkward process of falling in love.

Borison—already acclaimed for her Lovelight Farms series—once again proves her deft ability to breathe life into emotionally rich, imperfect characters whose flaws are as endearing as their strengths. In First-Time Caller, she crafts a romance that feels both personal and communal, echoing the shared, anonymous intimacy of radio itself.

If you’ve ever fallen for a grumpy radio host or wished real love was unscripted and raw, this book will hit you right in the heart. In this First-Time Caller summary, we unpack the narrative’s key moments, psychological depth, and romantic brilliance.

Plot Overview: Love on the Air

Set in a late-night radio booth clinging to relevance, First-Time Caller centers around Aiden Valentine, the disillusioned host of “Heartstrings” on 101.6 LITE FM, and Lucie Stone, a single mother thrust into the spotlight when her daughter Maya secretly dials into the show. Aiden’s detachment from love—and, by extension, his audience—is palpable: he views romance as a “fairy tale now,” a sentiment born from personal grief and professional fatigue. Lucie, on the other hand, is quietly yearning—not for grand passion, but for recognition, connection, and maybe even a second chance at being “an idiot without consequence.”

Their first encounter, catalyzed by Maya’s earnest concern, is electric. Lucie’s honesty about loneliness and lost time sparks something dormant in Aiden. Her call becomes a viral sensation, and the station, desperate for a revival, invites her to become a recurring guest in search of love. What follows is a meta-romantic experiment—a public search for connection that gradually transforms into a very private, deeply affecting love story.

First-Time Caller Table of Contents

• Chapter 1 to Chapter 32
  
• Epilogue
  
• Acknowledgements
  
• About the Author

First-Time Caller Best Quotes

On Love and Magic

• “I want to feel something when I connect with someone. I want sparks. The good kind, you know? I want to laugh and mean it. I want goose bumps. I want to wonder what my date is thinking about and hope it might be me. I want…I want the magic.”

• “I want goose bumps. I want to be wanted. All this time and I—I haven’t given up. I guess I’m just waiting for it to find me.”

On Vulnerability and Self-Worth

• “I’m allowed to want soft, special things.”

• “It feels like every time I get my hopes up for something good, reality comes out swinging. I don’t know how to be a hopeful person anymore.”

• “I don’t want to try. All I do is try. All day long, I’m trying and I’m so tired. Why can’t this be the one thing I don’t have to try at?”

On Being a Romantic and Wanting More

• “When the whole world tells you you’re silly… [full version of quote that blends vulnerability and romantic ideals].”

• “I like that. Thinking that I’m worth paying attention to. Something ordinary made extraordinary by the person you’re sharing it with.”

On Connection and Conversations

• “Long-time listener, first-time caller,” he says over the line. There’s a reluctant grin in his voice.

• “I want to keep Lucie on the line. I want something different.”

• “I’m not trying to fix anything for you, Lucie. I’m just gonna listen.”

• “I love when we do this. When he says my name and then I say his. Fond exasperation and gentle amusement in every syllable.”

Moments of Tenderness and Longing

• “I’m thinking about her, about us, about this. About this tiny café across from her house and all the places we almost met.”

• “I don’t want to let her go yet. I want to hold on to this feeling for a little longer.”

• “I imagine somewhere in this sprawling city, Lucie is smiling. For one night at least.”

• “Ah, Lucie.” Aiden smiles, his fingers fanning out wide against my back. “I’d know you anywhere.”

❤️‍ On Love That Endures

• “Every day isn’t a fairy tale. We’ve worked hard for our relationship. To build it. To maintain it. I’ve become so many versions of myself and so has he, but we’ve found a way to fall in love with one another over and over again.”

• “But there’s magic too. In between the hard work, there are perfect moments where everything lines up exactly right.”

Whimsical, Fun, and Personal

• “Aiden looks like a brooding Disney prince in a Carhartt hoodie.”

• “I think books are sexy,” she says very seriously. “No one at school has quite lived up to Aragorn yet.”

• “I don’t concern myself with the fragile egos of men.”

• “For the hopeless romantics. And the reluctant ones too.”

About the Author: Who Is B.K. Borison?

B.K. Borison is a rising voice in contemporary romance, known for her ability to infuse heartfelt stories with humor, warmth, and emotional authenticity. Best known for her Lovelight Farms series, Borison’s writing often revolves around small towns, complex emotional journeys, and characters who feel like your best friends—or the people you wish you were brave enough to love.

Borison’s strength lies in capturing the magic of ordinary moments and elevating them into transformative experiences. With First-Time Caller, she offers a poignant love story that challenges our assumptions about connection, vulnerability, and the risks we take for love.

First-Time Caller Summary Chapter-by-Chapter

Chapter 1: The Accidental Call

Lucie Stone, a single mother balancing work and parenting, accidentally dials into a late-night radio advice show hosted by the guarded and grumpy Aiden Valentine. Her vulnerability on-air strikes a chord with listeners—and unexpectedly with Aiden himself. The call goes viral, changing both their lives.

Chapter 2–5: A Viral Sensation

Lucie becomes a recurring guest on the show, and the station leans into her popularity. A segment is launched: First-Time Caller Dating Experience. Suddenly, Lucie is dating for an audience while Aiden plays the unwilling matchmaker.

The chemistry between them grows, even as they maintain their professional distance—barely.

Chapter 6–10: Performing Romance

Lucie’s dating adventures are full of awkward charm and comedic flops. Meanwhile, Aiden begins to sabotage the dates subtly—until it’s clear even to him that he’s falling for her. Their witty on-air banter becomes the beating heart of the show.

But can anything real survive when the whole world is listening?

Chapter 11–14: Closet Confessions

One unforgettable scene—locked in a recording closet—breaks all tension. It’s sensual, emotional, and reveals everything they’ve both tried to hide.

“I’ve been wanting you,” Aiden whispers, as professional boundaries collapse.

Chapter 15–18: The Breakdown

Aiden pulls away, terrified of what he’s feeling. Lucie, tired of pretending, takes a step back too. The radio show becomes a shell of what it was—highlighting how love and honesty were always its core.

Chapter 19–21: On-Air Truth

Aiden surprises everyone by calling into his own show. On-air, live, he asks Lucie the one question he swore he’d never ask:

“What does it feel like when you fall in love?”

It’s his grand gesture. Vulnerable. Public. Real.

Chapter 22-32: The Real Love Story

The show ends, but their story begins—for real, off the air. Lucie and Aiden finally choose each other, imperfect and raw, but true.

Emotional Depth: Themes That Resonate

1. The Illusion of Control

Both Lucie and Aiden use emotional armor—Lucie hides behind practicality; Aiden hides behind cynicism. The radio show forces both to confront the truth: love is messy, real, and beautifully out of control.

2. Vulnerability Is Power

Lucie’s honesty sparks the entire story. She becomes a symbol of emotional bravery in a world that rewards filters and facades. Her openness invites Aiden to risk it all—live, on-air.

3. The Performance of Love

The radio becomes a metaphor for modern relationships: curated, performative, and guarded. Only when the mics go off does the real connection begin.

Meet the Characters: Who Makes This Story Shine?

‍♀️ Lucie Stone – The Reluctant Star

• Strengths: Resilient, kind, emotionally intelligent

• Flaws: Self-doubt, nostalgic idealism

• Arc: Learns to stop performing and start living

• Best Moment: Realizing Aiden’s affection is behind all the orchestrated dates

️ Aiden Valentine – The Grumpy Heartthrob

• Strengths: Loyal, protective, deeply intuitive

• Flaws: Emotionally closed, fears abandonment

• Arc: Learns that love is a choice, not a myth

• Best Moment: His live confession on-air—an ultimate act of vulnerability

Maya (Lucie’s daughter)

The unexpected bridge between two adults afraid to fall in love.

‍ Jackson (Aiden’s coworker)

Provides comic relief and pressure-release for Aiden’s emotional tension.

Maggie (Station Manager)

Represents external conflict—ratings, pressure, and performance over authenticity.

What Makes First-Time Caller So Special?

Unique Hook

A radio love story in the age of podcasts? It’s clever, timely, and deeply nostalgic.

Emotional Authenticity

It’s not just about falling in love—it’s about earning it, through pain, risk, and growth.

Role Reversals

Here, the woman is the heart-on-her-sleeve romantic, and the man is emotionally guarded—a subtle but refreshing shift in romance tropes.

Real-Life Relevance

• Single Parenthood: Lucie’s character will resonate with anyone balancing selflessness and self-worth.

• Post-Pandemic Loneliness: Aiden’s arc echoes how isolation alters emotional expression.

• Media as a Mirror: The show reflects the ways we present ourselves—and what it means to be truly seen.

Strengths vs. Weaknesses

✅ Strengths

• Dynamic banter

• Authentic vulnerability

• Fresh setting and premise

• Excellent pacing and emotional beats

❌ Weaknesses

• Side characters could use deeper development

• Some plot twists are predictable (though comforting for romance readers)

Final Verdict: Should You Read First-Time Caller?

Absolutely. If you love:

• Grumpy/sunshine dynamics

• Radio or audio-themed storytelling

• Romance with real emotional arcs

• Books about second chances and healing

Then First-Time Caller is your next obsession.

⭐ Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)

Who Is This Book For?

• Fans of Emily Henry, Abby Jimenez, or Sally Thorne

• Podcast or radio show lovers

• Readers who crave emotionally intelligent romances

• Anyone healing from heartbreak and still willing to hope

Final Thoughts

First-Time Caller is more than a love story. It’s a reminder that being seen, truly seen, is the beginning of healing. With compelling characters, witty banter, and tear-worthy vulnerability, this is a book that lingers.

So, whether you’re a romance reader or a first-time caller into love yourself—pick this up. It might just change your frequency.

Have you read First-Time Caller? What did you think of Aiden’s on-air confession? Drop your thoughts in the comments!

Get Your Copy

• First-Time Caller by B.K. Borison
• Explore Similar Books

Attachments & References

• Amazon’s book page
• Goodreaders’s book page
• Author’s image source: penguinrandomhouse.com
• Book Cover: Amazon.com
• Quote sources: Goodreads