Things We Never Got Over Summary by Lucy Score – A Journey of Love

Things We Never Got Over Summary – A Journey of Love, Family, and Healing

Introduction: What Happens When Your Past Isn’t So Simple?

Have you ever been thrown into a situation where everything goes wrong, and the people around you only make things harder? Naomi Witt faces this exact dilemma in Things We Never Got Over by Lucy Score.

From the very first page, Naomi’s life unravels as she’s mistakenly blamed for her sister’s misdeeds, dragged into a small-town drama, and unexpectedly becomes the guardian of a niece she didn’t know existed.

This Things We Never Got Over Summary will take you through Naomi’s rollercoaster of emotions, as she tackles her sister’s chaos, forms new connections, and learns what it really means to heal. Will she overcome the weight of her past or be trapped by it forever?

Quick Summary – TL;DR:

• Key Insights: Family, trauma, and love intertwine in this emotional romance.

• Rating: 4.5/5 – A must-read for fans of emotional character-driven stories.

• Primary Audience: Romance lovers, readers who enjoy character-driven plots with emotional depth.

• Pros: Strong chemistry between characters, a gripping plot.

• Cons: Some moments might feel emotionally intense for some readers.

Reader Reviews about Things We Never Got Over

1. “A story of love and healing that will have you laughing, crying, and rooting for Naomi and Knox from start to finish!” – Goodreads Review

2. “Lucy Score delivers another hit with this emotionally rich and thrilling love story.” – Amazon Review

3. “Knox is the brooding hero we didn’t know we needed, and Naomi’s journey is so relatable.” – Goodreads Review

4. “A perfect mix of humor, romance, and a bit of suspense. Highly recommend this book!” – Amazon Review

5. “The characters are so well-developed. You feel like they’re your friends by the end of the book.” – Goodreads Review

Questions Things We Never Got Over Answers

1. What makes Naomi the perfect heroine in this story?

2. How does Knox’s past influence his actions toward Naomi?

3. What role does Waylay play in Naomi’s transformation?

4. How does the small-town setting impact the story’s events?

5. What does Things We Never Got Over say about the power of community?

6. How do the relationships in the book evolve over time?

7. What makes Knox’s character arc so compelling?

8. How does Naomi’s journey reflect themes of self-discovery?

9. What does Tina’s presence in the story symbolize?

10. How do the conflicts in the book resolve, and what is the final message?

Things We Never Got Over Summary & Plot Summary

Naomi Witt’s life takes a turn for the worse on what she dubs her “Worst. Day. Ever.” Walking into a café, she’s confronted by a picture of herself with the words “Do Not Serve” plastered across it. Naomi, already exhausted from life’s chaos, tries to stay calm but finds herself face-to-face with Knox, a brooding man who mistakenly believes she’s her sister, Tina. Tina’s reputation precedes her, and it seems Naomi is constantly having to clean up after her twin’s messes.

Knox, a local “Viking-like” man, is not thrilled about the confusion, and after a heated argument, he offers Naomi a ride, which she reluctantly accepts. What starts as a tense drive soon reveals Naomi’s new reality: her sister Tina has stolen her car, and Naomi is left to deal with the consequences.

As Naomi adjusts to her new life in Knockemout, she discovers that Tina not only left behind her car but also an eleven-year-old niece, Waylay, who Naomi didn’t even know existed. This bombshell forces Naomi to step up and become Waylay’s guardian, a role she is woefully unprepared for. But Naomi isn’t alone. Alongside the gruff, protective Knox, and his eccentric family, Naomi starts to rebuild her life, only to find herself falling for Knox despite his fear of commitment.

Things We Never Got Over Summary By Chapter

1. Worst. Day. Ever

Naomi arrives in Knockemout, mistaken for her sister Tina, and has a tense encounter with Knox, who is furious with Tina for causing trouble in town.

2. A Reluctant Hero

Knox offers Naomi a ride, still holding a grudge against her sister. Tensions rise as they navigate their first meeting.

3. A Pint-Sized Criminal

Naomi discovers Tina has abandoned her 11-year-old daughter, Waylay, in her motel room, which sets Naomi on a path of responsibility.

4. “You’re Not Staying Here”

Knox refuses to let Naomi and Waylay stay at the motel or Tina’s trailer, insisting on taking them to a charming cottage instead.

5. A Vat of Lighter Fluid and a Nap

Exhausted, Naomi takes a much-needed nap after moving into the cottage, while Nash starts taking care of Waylay.

6. Asparagus and a Showdown

Mistaken for Tina again, Naomi gets into a confrontation at the grocery store but is later offered a job by Sherry Fiasco.

7. A Punch in the Face

Knox and his brother Nash engage in a fight, and Naomi discovers that her car was reported stolen by her ex-fiancé, Warner.

8. The Mysterious Liza J

Naomi meets Liza J, Knox and Nash’s grandmother, who offers Naomi and Waylay a free stay in exchange for cleaning and babysitting.

9. Backyard Urination & Dewey Decimal

Naomi witnesses Knox peeing in his backyard and later takes Waylay to the library, where Waylay impresses the librarian.

10. Hair Cuts and Pains in the Ass

Knox hires Naomi to work at his bar, Honky Tonk, secretly researching her past and Tina’s criminal record.

11. Boss from Hell

Naomi struggles with her new job at Honky Tonk, dealing with customers who mistake her for Tina and Knox’s difficult attitude.

12. A Ride Home

Knox ensures Naomi gets home safely and informs her that her stolen car has been found dismantled.

13. History Lessons

Naomi adjusts to life in Knockemout, learning about the local gossip and family dynamics involving Knox and Nash.

14. The Dinner Party

Knox and Jeremiah attend a dinner at Naomi’s cottage, where Waylay earns money fixing tech, and CPS worker Yolanda Suarez makes a brief visit.

15. Knox Goes Shopping

Naomi uses the money from selling her wedding dress to buy Waylay school supplies, and Knox surprises them by buying Waylay new shoes and Naomi a phone.

16. The Infamous Stef

Naomi’s best friend, Stef, arrives, causing tension between her and Knox, and helps with Naomi’s house sale.

17. Man-to-Man

(No specific details provided.)

18. Makeovers for Everyone

Stef takes Naomi and Waylay for makeovers at Knox’s salon, where Waylay reveals Tina cut her hair as punishment, and Knox offers a supportive pep talk.

19. High Stakes

Naomi works a high-stakes poker game at Honky Tonk, which causes Knox concern due to the dangerous individuals involved.

20. A Winning Hand

Naomi distracts Nash from the poker game and wins $22,000, surprising everyone, including Knox.

21. Family Emergency

Naomi starts her new library job and learns that Nash has been shot, rushing to the hospital to comfort Knox.

22. One Hatchet Two Bullets

Knox and Nash discuss the shooting incident while Lucian joins them at the hospital.

23. Knox Knox. Who’s There?

Naomi wakes up to find she and Knox have shared an intimate moment, marking a new, deeper connection.

24. Uninvited Guests

Naomi’s parents arrive unexpectedly, and Knox pretends to be in a serious relationship with Naomi for Waylay’s guardianship.

25. Family Fuss

With Nash recovering, the Witt family plans to clean his apartment, while Stef reveals multiple purchase offers for Naomi’s house.

26. PMS and the Bully

Naomi learns that Knox provides “period survival kits” for his female staff. She also discovers Waylay is being bullied by her teacher.

27. Field Mice Revenge

Waylay attempts “field mice revenge” after Naomi confronts her teacher, Mrs. Felch, for bullying her.

28. Third Base

Knox and Naomi share a physical encounter at a secluded spot, deepening their relationship.

29. Knox’s House

Naomi stays at Knox’s cabin, built by his grandfather, marking an intimate step in their relationship.

30. Breakfast of Shame

Naomi and Knox maintain their fake relationship during a family breakfast, while Nash’s recovery is announced.

31. Shifty in the Stacks

Naomi encounters a suspicious man, Flint, and deals with more unresolved issues, including an email from Warner.

32. Lunch and a Warning

Knox and Naomi discuss Tina’s criminal activities, leading Naomi to help Nash with a wound.

33. A Swift Kick

Waylay gets a yellow card during a soccer game, while Nash reveals more about Tina’s criminal activities.

34. The Groom

(No specific details provided.)

35. The Whole Story and a Happy Ending

Warner appears at Honky Tonk, prompting Knox to attack him, and Naomi finally confides in Knox about her past abuse.

36. The Break-In

Naomi’s cottage is broken into while Knox, Nash, and Lucian discuss Tina’s criminal network.

37. Shave and a Haircut

Knox and Jeremiah offer free haircuts to the homeless, revealing Knox’s compassionate side.

38. F.I.N.E

Knox breaks up with Naomi publicly, citing her complexity, leaving Naomi heartbroken.

39. Breaking Up, Down, and Through

Naomi seeks comfort from her friends and family after the breakup, focusing on self-care and resilience.

40. The Consequences of Being an Idiot

Knox regrets the breakup and faces consequences for pushing Naomi away, including being confronted by Nash and Lucian.

41. The New Naomi

Stef encourages Naomi to embrace a new persona focused on self-care, while Waylay expresses anger at Knox for leaving.

42. The Old Knox

Knox struggles with Naomi’s avoidance and realizes he has made a mistake, leading to deep regret.

43. Day Drinking

Naomi drinks with Lina and Sloane, and later witnesses Knox with his ex-girlfriend, heightening her emotional turmoil.

44. The Babysitters

(No specific details provided.)

45. The Bar Fight

Knox confronts Naomi, revealing his fear of commitment rooted in his father’s abandonment after his mother’s death.

46. Tina Sucks

Tina kidnaps Naomi and Waylay, seeking a flash drive containing sensitive information about a crime syndicate.

47. Missing

Naomi and Waylay’s disappearance prompts a search, leading to the discovery of the broken fence and Duncan Hugo’s involvement.

48. The Ol’ Switcheroo

Naomi and Waylay plan a switch to help Waylay escape from Tina and Duncan Hugo, using a clever code phrase.

49. The Cavalry

Knox, Nash, and Lucian rescue Naomi and Waylay, and Knox proposes to Naomi. The town rallies behind them, and Waylay’s adoption process is finalized with Tina’s consent.

Main Characters and Their Arcs

Naomi Witt
Naomi is the protagonist of the story. A “good girl” with a penchant for people-pleasing, Naomi’s life takes an unexpected turn when she has to confront the mistakes of her twin sister Tina. Naomi quickly shifts from a woman on the run to a fierce protector of her niece, Waylay. Her journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns to stand up for herself, let go of her past, and embrace her role as a guardian and as a woman capable of love and strength.

Knox Morgan
The grumpy, tattooed Knox may appear tough, but beneath the surface, he’s dealing with his own trauma. As a lottery winner who could have had it all, Knox chose a quieter life. His protective instincts kick in when Naomi enters his life, and while he keeps pushing her away due to his fear of vulnerability, his actions speak louder than his words. Knox’s character arc is about breaking down emotional walls and learning to trust and commit to someone he loves.

Waylay Witt
Naomi’s eleven-year-old niece, Waylay, is a brilliant tech-savvy girl who has had a rough start in life, mainly due to Tina’s instability. Waylay’s character represents resilience as she slowly opens up to Naomi, forming a bond that will shape Naomi’s journey forward.

Tina Witt
Naomi’s estranged twin sister, Tina, is the antagonist in the story. With a criminal record and a penchant for causing chaos, Tina’s actions force Naomi into situations she never anticipated. Despite her reckless behavior, Tina’s influence over Naomi’s life can’t be denied.

Nash Morgan
Knox’s brother and the Chief of Police, Nash is everything that Knox isn’t. He’s charming, ethical, and driven by a sense of duty. Despite his brother’s gruff demeanor, Nash plays a key role in helping Naomi navigate her new responsibilities and the challenges surrounding Tina’s actions.

Book Themes & Analysis

About the Author: Lucy Score

Who Is Lucy Score?

Lucy Score is a New York Times and USA Today bestselling author known for her heartwarming, steamy small-town romances packed with humor, sizzling chemistry, and lovable communities. She’s the master of feel-good love stories that balance laugh-out-loud moments with deep emotional connections.

Quick Facts

• Born: 1980s (age undisclosed) in Pennsylvania.

• Genres: Contemporary romance, rom-com, small-town romance, romantic suspense.

• Claim to Fame: Things We Never Got Over (2022) became a viral BookTok sensation.

• Writing Style: Witty banter, strong heroines, grumpy-sunshine pairings, and small-town charm.

Her Most Popular Books

Knockemout Series (Small-Town Romance)

1. Things We Never Got Over (2022)

   • Trope: Grumpy/sunshine + runaway bride.

   • Plot: Naomi flees her wedding and ends up in Knockemout, Virginia, where gruff barber Knox becomes her unlikely protector.

   • Why It’s Loved: BookTok obsessed, hilarious chaos, and slow-burn passion.

2. Things We Hide from the Light (2023)

   • Trope: Broken hero + fierce heroine.

   • Plot: Police chief Nash (Knox’s brother) falls for his mysterious new neighbor, Lina.

   • Why It’s Loved: Emotional depth, suspense, and steamy romance.

3. Things We Left Behind (2023)

   • Trope: Enemies-to-lovers + second chance.

   • Plot: Lucian (Knox’s best friend) and Sloane’s explosive history resurfaces.

   • Why It’s Loved: Angsty, fiery, and deeply emotional.

Standalone Rom-Coms

• By a Thread (2020) – Grumpy boss/employee romance with The Hating Game vibes.

• The Worst Best Man (2020) – Wedding planner falls for her ex’s brother.

• Rock Bottom Girl (2019) – A hilarious second-chance romance about a woman returning to her hometown.

Blue Moon Series (Small-Town Romance)

• No More Secrets (2018) – A runaway bride and a sexy farmer.

• Fall Into Temptation (2018) – Single mom and a reformed bad boy.

Why Readers Love Lucy Score

✅ Addictive Grumpy-Sunshine Pairings – Her brooding heroes (Knox, Lucian) are legendary.
✅ Hilarious & Heartfelt – Expect laugh-out-loud moments mixed with deep emotion.
✅ Small-Town Vibes – Quirky side characters, tight-knit communities, and cozy settings.
✅ STEAMY Slow Burns – The tension is chef’s kiss.

FAQ :

Q: Is Things We Never Got Over a standalone novel?
Yes, Things We Never Got Over is a standalone novel by Lucy Score, though it contains recurring characters from other works.

Q: What genre is Things We Never Got Over?
It’s a romance novel with a mix of humor, emotional depth, and suspense.

Q: Who would enjoy this book?
If you enjoy heartfelt romance with complex characters and a strong community setting, this book is for you.

Conclusion: Things We Never Got Over Summary by Lucy Score

Why You Need to Read Things We Never Got Over

If you’re looking for a romance that’s equal parts heartwarming and heart-wrenching, Things We Never Got Over Summary brings you a journey of growth, love, and resilience.

Naomi and Knox’s story proves that even the messiest situations can lead to unexpected and fulfilling love.

Don’t miss out—grab your copy and dive into the world of Knockemout today!